There are definitions for the six conditions of the just war doctrine, and analysis of the war with respect to the six principles of a just war. The bush doctrine as a hegemonic discourse strategy. Prevention, preemption, and the bush doctrine dtic. While no patriotic american wants to see his country as being on the wrong side of an international conflict, especially after 91101, we still want to ask ourselves if the devil so to speak is in the details. The bush doctrine is a phrase used to describe various related foreign policy principles of the 43rd president of the united states, george w.
Firstly, it is important to establish what just war theory is and what it says. The bush doctrine and just war theory words count 269 is the bush doctrine one of preemption or prevention. It is based in large part on the weinberger doctrine, devised by caspar weinberger, former secretary of defense and powells former boss. The blair doctrine and its interpretation in history 19972007 exemplify a britain reliving the past in its foreign affairs ideology. The phrase was first used by charles krauthammer in june 2001 to describe the bush administrations unilaterally withdrawing from the abm treaty and rejecting the kyoto protocol. Pdf the principles of the just war doctrine and the. Gilsonjust war and preventive force doctrines 1 just war and preventive force doctrines. Further, a just war can only be fought with right intentions. It has a long historical tradition that dates back to medieval times. In doing so, it will call for a rejection of the bush doctrine of preemptive war in order. Would the united states doctrine of preventative war be. The official policy guiding this war, widely known as the bush doctrine, announced that no distinction would be made between terrorists and the rogue states that sponsor or harbor them. Articles just war theory power that saves us both from that moral excess and that political folly.
This book is a compendium of every important issue in just war theory. The arguments presented here will presuppose the cogency of the latter, conditional normative critique of bush doctrine preventive military policies. The bush administration rightly points to the changed nature of military threats and poses a dilemma for scholars of just war theory. Deaths and injury incurred in a hopeless cause are not morally justifiable. A preemptive war is a war that is commenced in an attempt to repel or defeat a perceived imminent offensive or invasion, or to gain a strategic advantage in an impending allegedly unavoidable war shortly before that attack materializes. Some midlevel officials think this is window dressing. The bush doctrine, in line with longstanding neoconservative ideas, held that the united states is entangled in a global war of ideas between the western values of freedom on the one hand, and extremism seeking to destroy them on the other. The bush doctrine of pre emption and the us response after. Our nations cause has always been larger than our nations defense. Understanding the bush doctrine high point university. After 911 the phrase described the policy that the united states had the right to. Chapter one just war doctrine and general order no. Kaufman connects the bush doctrine and current issues in american foreign policy, such as how the u. President bush strategy was devised to react and invade afghanistan where osama bin laden and al qaeda were under the so called.
Bush doctrine means as a speech act performed within the context of international political discourse, and to determine whether this speech act is normatively constructive or obfuscating. Overview of just war theory just war theory has a varied and diverse background. Nov 15, 2001 but further reflection upon just war theory may give us pause to rethink the current war. That wars goals, however, were limited to forcing iraq to abandon its occupation of kuwait and did not include toppling saddam. The bush doctrine of pre emption and the us response after 911 attacks. The bush doctrine and just war theory 121 the bush. The bush doctrine is more prevention than preemption.
We fight, as we always fight, for a just peacea peace that favors human liberty. The bush doctrine is a phrase used to describe various related foreign policy principles of former united states president george w. The broad thesis defended here is that the bush doctrine is a form of hegemonic discourse strategy. A war can only be just if it is fought with a reasonable chance of success. Pdf in defense of the bush doctrine download full pdf. The foreign policy of the bush doctrine was subject to controversy both in the united states and internationally. The bush doctrine has been described in various ways. The traditional focus of the theory was predominantly on two spheres namely. The ultimate goal of a just war is to reestablish peace. Does this new strategy, what is referred to as the bush doctrine, constitute a just, that is, morally justifiable, response to terrorism.
Now, let me say a word about the actual bush doctrine and what i think, what i take to beand this is based on no inside information just on, obviously, watching what he has said and done, what i take to be the presidents fundamental understanding of the world post911. Just as wilson sought to teach the countries of latin america to elect good men, so bush will bring free markets and free elections to countries without them. But the administrations doctrine is actually also a preventive war doctrine. Submitted to the department of religious studies and the faculty of the graduate school of the university of kansas in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts. Essay about the bush doctrine and just war theory 289 words. In defense of the bush doctrine provides a broader historical context for the postseptember 11 american foreign policy that will transform world politics well into the future. The assumption behind this strategy was that the cold war doctrines of. The bush doctrine and just war theory 121 the bush doctrine. A website that defines and explains bush s doctrine on preemptive selfdefense. Predicated on liberal humanitarian intervention and the just war theory, the blair doctrine of 19972007 is a sort of nostalgia. That war s goals, however, were limited to forcing iraq to abandon its occupation of kuwait and did not include toppling saddam. Thomas aquinas, preemption, and the just war tradition first appeared in the spring 2017 issue of providences print edition.
Just war theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy. However, it may prove more fruitful to evaluate each act of preemption resulting from the application of the doctrine for compatibility with the just war theory as opposed to the doctrine itself. Occasionally, skeptics of just war theory will also, for satirical effect, cite instances from the classical literature of causes for war that are now rejected but were once widely accepted as just, such as the punishment of wrongdoing and the spread of the christian religion. However, just war theory also acts to remind contenders that war is a last resort and that its essential aim is always peace, so if peace is forthcoming in any guise, it is morally critical for all parties to seek a return to a permanent peace rather than a momentary lapse of war. Lucas says that the doctrine of preemptive selfdefense is troubling in the modern political scheme. Just war theory and the 2003 decision to invade iraq. Bush has been widely regarded as having occasioned one of the most dramatic shifts in the history of american foreign policy.
Indeed, there is a strong case to be made, as dale t. Latin for right to war is a set of criteria that are to be consulted before engaging in war in order to determine whether entering into war is permissible, that is, whether it is a just war. Bush, created in the wake of the september 11, 2001 attacks. Terrorism and just war americas war on terrorism has once again raised important questions about the proper use of military action. After 911 the phrase described the policy that the united states. Jus ad bellum the right to go to war and jus in bello right conduct within war. S on iraq as an example of an american war that meets all the requirements of the just war doctrine. Further, by not saving war as a last resort after all negotiations have failed and after an actual attack, a clear act of war the bush doctrine opens the possibility that the u.
Kofi annan, commenting on the bush doctrine and preemptive force, noted that both were a fundamental challenge annan 2003. The bush doctrine grew out of neoconservative dissatisfaction with president bill clintons handling of the iraqi regime of saddam hussein in the 1990s. Some of the troubles that we have had in iraq after. These principles include unilateralism and the use of preemptive war. The just war theory attempts to conceive of how the use of arms might be restrained, made more. The lens through which this analysis is conducted is the moral calculus offered by the just war ethical tradition. Since then the bush doctrine of preemption has been put into effect in iraq. The bush doctrine refers to various related foreign policy principles of the 43rd president of the united states, george w. Pdf on september 11, 2001 the people of the united states and the world endured a heinous act of terrorism.
When martial force becomes necessary, the just war tradition has contributed nobly to mitigating the tragedy of war by. The bush doctrine and just war theory in the history of foreign policy and warfare relations between states have been often defined by the presupposition of. Michael walzers politics, in theory and practice the. Just war theory and a thoughtful realist one important theory within international relations shows a moral aspect on how to conduct war. Global reactions, global consequences mary buckley, robert singh the presidency of george w. The reagan doctrine was considered anticommunist and. Just war theory is the theory of permissible war that advocates just criteria for the launching of, conduct in and ending of war.
In doing so, it will call for a rejection of the bush doctrine of preemptive war in order to remain within the inherited theocentric just war tradition. The catholic church, which over the centuries has blessed many dreadful wars, is shifting to an antiwar position favored by pope francis and more in line with jesuss teachings, writes excia. Of course, the critics embrace of realism is cynical just another way to. Theory and practice william kristol, chairman of the project for the new american century. Despite these problems, i argue that just war theory is a useful method of inquiry into the problems of contemporary war. The justice of preemption and preventive war doctrines, pp. As such, it falls foul of the just war criterion of selfdefense. What has come to be known as the bush doctrine is an idealistic approach to international relations that imagines a world transformed by the promise of democracy and that sees military force as an appropriate means to utilize in pursuit of this goal. I then highlight some ways that warfare has changed in recent years, to facilitate an evaluation of whether just war theory is still an appropriate framework for shaping and assessing the morality of war. At the center of this war were a series of foreign policy decisions made by the administration of president george w. Proportionality the proportionality criterion cites that there must be due proportion.
The language used to describe the emerging strategy began to take shape during the presidents address at west point. The bush doctrine and just war theory researchgate. The development of the doctrine was influenced by neoconservative ideology, and it was considered to be a step from the political realism of the reagan doctrine. In order to answer that question the doctrine will be analyzed from a legal and political perspective, after having established what exactly is to be understood as the bush doctrine. Sep 09, 2009 the second key issue in the bush doctrine is the use of preemptive force as a legitimate strategy of defence. Invasion of afghanistan and iraq shahid ali khattak. The bush doctrine, democratization, and humanitarian. The bush doctrine declared america could launch first strikes to defend itself from terrorists and countries that supported terrorists in order to prevent possible attacks before they occurred.
Snauwaert has argued, that from the perspective of the just war tradition the bush doctrines linkage with a powerdriven, hegemonic. Michael walzer on just war theory big think youtube. September 11 created the conditions for the new bush administration to do just that. What has come to be known as the bush doctrine is an idealistic approach to international. Shalom argues that the war in afghanistan and pakistan is unjust because it has violated the principles of last resort, right authority and proportionality.
If we wait for threats to fully materialise, we will have waited too long bush 2002. Is the bush doctrine of preventive war a necessary broadening or a risky contortion of the concept of preemptive selfdefense. The phrase was first used by charles krauthammer in june 2001 1 to describe the bush administrations unilateral withdrawals from the abm treaty and the kyoto protocol. This agenda horrifies realists and perhaps realists. The powell doctrine is a journalistcreated term, named after general colin powell in the runup to the 199091 gulf war. The bush doctrine of preemptive selfdefense philosophy talk. Dowd, the bush doctrines principle of preemption was tailormade for. Just war paper just war paper dale t snauwaert had.
This doctrine is argued to be contrary to the just war theory and would. The bush doctrine of pre emption and the us response after 9. Agreeing with the bush administration that war is transformed, i. Abstract the war on terror is the policy response of the us to the 911 attacks on us.
Jun 05, 2012 further, by not saving war as a last resort after all negotiations have failed and after an actual attack, a clear act of war the bush doctrine opens the possibility that the u. International law and the bush doctrine einternational relations. The bush doctrine is a phrase used to describe various related foreign policy principles of united states president george w. The reagan doctrine was considered key to american foreign policy until the end of the cold war, just before bill clinton became president of the united states. In fact, it sounds a lot like the justification for the iraq war. Lucas says that preemptive selfdefense is warranted when the threat is imminent. The justice of preemption and preventive war doctrines. The trump doctrine sounds suspiciously like the bush. Pdf the bush doctrine and just war theory dale snauwaert. The just war tradition includes the contributions of philosophers and theologians dating back to roman times, including, most notably, its recognition and study by such historical thinkers as cicero, st. Liberal dreams and international realities a liberal hegemonic policy like the bush doctrine is ineffective at achieving its stated end goals and is doomed to lead to more war, antiamericanism, a global retreat. The powell doctrine states that a list of questions all have to be answered affirmatively before military action is taken.
Pope francis takes on just war theory consortiumnews. Mearsheimer argues in his book, the great delusion. The online journal of peace and conflict resolution6. Today i had a seminar on just war theory, the theory of when it is justifiable for one state to go to war with another. Some have suggested that trump doesnt actually have a doctrine i. Snauwaert had impressive points about the bush doctrine and the just war theory.
Pdf the bush doctrine and just war theory researchgate. The second key issue in the bush doctrine is the use of preemptive force as a legitimate strategy of defence. The history and application of christian just war theory as related to preemptive attack. I was drawing on an intellectual tradition i didnt know much about, so i began to read catholic justwar theory, and the book is really a secularization of catholic justwar doctrine. The essential role of democracy in the bush doctrine scielo. Bush said on september 20, 2001, whether we bring our enemies to justice, or justice to our enemies, justice will be done. Bush, which we collectively call the bush doctrine. Just war theory is a doctrine of military ethics from a philosophical and catholic viewpoint. Throughout the seminar, it continued to strike me that just war theory in and of itself is a mistaken concept. The history and application of christian just war theory.
655 602 1001 669 5 904 177 333 1129 1323 518 905 1477 522 447 1222 413 1328 1324 358 542 759 380 937 804 536 580 1041